Top Headlines

Feeds

Alabama Governor Commutes Death Row Inmate’s Sentence After 30 Years

Updated Published Cached

Alabama governor commutes death row inmate’s sentence Gov. Kay Ivey announced Tuesday that Charles “Sonny” Burton’s death sentence is reduced to life without parole, halting his scheduled execution on Thursday. [1]

Ivey cites Burton’s non‑shooter role as conscience issue Ivey said she could not proceed in good conscience because Burton did not fire the fatal shot, insisting the triggerman already received life without parole. [1]

Burton convicted under felony‑murder law for 1991 robbery In August 1991 Burton and five men robbed an AutoZone in Talladega; co‑defendant Derrick DeBruce shot store clerk Douglas Battle, yet a 1992 jury sentenced Burton to death for capital felony murder despite his absence at the killing. [1]

Clemency in Alabama is exceptionally rare Less than one‑half of one percent of death‑penalty inmates have received clemency, and Ivey has granted it only once during her tenure, according to the Death Penalty Information Center. [2]

Victim’s family and jurors backed the commutation The victim’s daughter and six of eight living jurors wrote letters urging Ivey to spare Burton, with jurors stating the sentence now seems unjust and inconsistent with the shooter’s life‑without‑parole term. [1]

Burton’s severe health problems cited in petition The clemency petition notes Burton’s rheumatoid arthritis, wheelchair confinement, recent stroke, and a diagnosed delusional disorder, factors his lawyers argued make execution inhumane. [1]

  • Kay Ivey (Alabama governor): “I could not proceed in good conscience… He will now receive the same punishment as the triggerman.”
  • Charles “Sonny” Burton (inmate, via lawyer): Expressed gratitude, saying, “Just saying thank you doesn’t seem like much… I do thank her. Thank you, Governor.”
  • Lois Harris (Burton’s daughter): Told CNN she felt “a weight was lifted off her shoulders” and called the decision “the right decision.”
  • Matt Schulz (Burton’s attorney of 17 years): Called the commutation “remarkable,” noting Burton was “overjoyed” and “extremely grateful” to Ivey.
  • Priscilla Townsend (former juror): Stated she no longer agrees with the death sentence, saying the disparity “didn’t sit right” given Burton didn’t pull the trigger.
  • James Cottingim (former juror): Said the sentencing disparity is “no longer appropriate,” highlighting that DeBruce’s resentencing to life made Burton’s death penalty “unjust.”

Links