Judge Frees Ecuadorian Father and 5‑Year‑Old Son, Sparking Dispute Over Abandonment Claims
Updated (19 articles)
Judge Biery’s Order Condemns Deportation‑Quota Policy
U.S. District Judge Fred Biery issued an emergency ruling ordering the immediate release of 5‑year‑old Liam Ramos and his father Adrian Conejo Arias, describing the detention as a product of “ill‑conceived… daily deportation quotas” and invoking the Declaration of Independence and biblical passages to criticize the government’s approach [4][7][10]. The order required the pair be freed “as soon as practicable” and no later than February 3, effectively halting any removal or transfer [8][11]. Biery’s opinion highlighted the legal controversy over administrative warrants used to arrest migrants [2][10].
Detention Began in Minnesota and Involved a 1,300‑Mile Transfer
ICE agents seized the father and son on Jan. 20 in the Minneapolis suburb of Columbia Heights, stopping their vehicle in the driveway before transporting them to the South Texas Family Residential Center in Dilley, a facility built for family detention [2][5][9]. Images of the boy in a blue bunny hat and Spider‑Man backpack circulated widely, fueling public outrage [2][9][10]. The distance of roughly 1,300 miles underscored the federal government’s practice of moving families far from their communities [2][5].
Father Asserts Legal Entry and Denies Abandonment; DHS Claims He Fled
Adrian Conejo Arias told ABC News he entered the United States legally in December 2024, filed an asylum claim, and would never leave his son, alleging that Liam fell ill in detention and was denied medication [1][4]. DHS Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin countered that the father fled on foot, abandoning the child, and that ICE officers kept the boy safe while arresting the father [1][6][10]. The family’s attorney, Marc Prokosch, reiterated that the asylum application was properly filed and that the father has no criminal record [2][5][12].
Congressional Escort and State Officials Praise the Release
Democratic Representative Joaquin Castro personally escorted the pair from Dilley back to Minnesota on Sunday, posting photos of the reunion on social media [5][6][7]. Governor Tim Walz and Rep. Ilhan Omar joined the praise, calling the court order a necessary correction and urging broader immigration reform [2][5][7]. The release occurred amid President Donald Trump’s intensified immigration enforcement, including the appointment of border adviser Tom Homan [1].
Disputed “Bait” Tactic and Child’s Health Concerns Remain Unresolved
Neighbors and school officials allege ICE officers instructed Liam to knock on his front door to lure his mother, a claim DHS labeled an “abject lie” [3][8][11][12]. Congressman Castro reported the boy appeared “very depressed,” was not eating, and slept excessively during the detention [8]. While the family’s asylum case continues, the incident has become a focal point for criticism of ICE’s family‑detention practices and the conditions at the Dilley facility [7][10].
Sources
-
1.
AP: Father of Detained 5‑Year‑Old Disputes Abandonment Claims – Details the father’s denial, DHS abandonment narrative, judge’s release order, and political context .
-
2.
CNN: Judge Frees 5‑Year‑Old Liam Ramos and Father After Texas Detention – Highlights the judge’s ruling, the 1,300‑mile transport, asylum filing, and the administration’s intent to appeal .
-
3.
AP: Minnesota Boy and Father Freed from Texas ICE Detention – Reports the release, officials’ reactions, and pending asylum status .
-
4.
BBC: Boy and Father Detained by ICE Return Home After Judge Orders Release – Covers the release, judge’s condemnation, protests, and school officials’ account of a “bait” tactic .
-
5.
CNN: 5‑Year‑Old Liam Ramos and Father Released From Texas ICE Detention – Focuses on Castro’s escort, judge’s criticism, and conflicting DHS/ICE statements about the mother .
-
6.
Newsweek: 5‑Year‑Old Liam Ramos and Father Released After ICE Detention – Emphasizes the judge’s order, Castro’s escort, and superintendent’s claim of bait .
-
7.
King5: Judge Orders Release of 5‑Year‑Old Boy and Father from Texas ICE Facility – Notes the judge’s moral language, detention details, and center condition complaints .
-
8.
Newsweek: Judge Orders Release of Ecuadorian Father and 5‑Year‑Old Son Detained by ICE – Provides timeline of seizure, DHS “abandonment” claim, and health observations by Castro .
-
9.
BBC: Boy and Father Detained by ICE Return Home After Judge Orders Release – Describes the emergency release, national protests, and political statements .
-
10.
AP: Judge orders release of detained 5‑year‑old and father in Texas – Highlights viral images, judge’s rebuke of quota policy, and White House arrest target .
-
11.
AP: Judge Blocks Deportation of Detained Ecuadorian Boy and Father – Reports temporary block, “bait” allegation, and lawmakers’ criticism .
-
12.
CNN: Federal Judge Halts Deportation of Minnesota Preschooler and Father – Details the stay of removal, father’s illegal‑alien label, and lawsuit against DHS officials .
Timeline
Dec 14, 2024 – Adrian Conejo Arias receives parole at the Brownsville port of entry, allowing him and his son Liam to remain in the U.S. while their asylum claim proceeds[9].
Dec 17, 2024 – The Conejo family files a pending asylum application, asserting they entered legally, complied with all procedures, and pose no flight risk[10].
Jan 20, 2026 – ICE agents seize Adrian Conejo Arias and his five‑year‑old son Liam from their driveway in Columbia Heights, a Minneapolis suburb, and transport them 1,300 miles to the South Texas Family Residential Center in Dilley, Texas[10][19].
Jan 22, 2026 – DHS states the operation targets the father, not the child, and claims the father fled, abandoning his son, while ICE posts on X that officers keep the child safe[3][8].
Jan 23, 2026 – Columbia Heights school officials allege ICE officers used Liam as “bait,” instructing him to knock on his door to lure his mother, a claim DHS calls an “abject lie”[7][11].
Jan 23, 2026 – Trump administration officials tell reporters the boy remains with his father at the Dilley facility and that agents cared for him, emphasizing he is not separated[11].
Jan 23, 2026 – Community fundraising surpasses $200,000 to support the family’s release, reflecting national outcry[11].
Jan 24, 2026 – The 2023 “Detained Parents Directive” requires ICE to allow parents to arrange alternate care for children, highlighting legal tension with the Dilley detention[17].
Jan 25, 2026 – Dozens of immigrant families protest outside the Dilley center, chanting “Libertad para los niños” and demanding the release of Liam and his father[16].
Jan 27, 2026 – U.S. District Judge Fred Biery issues a temporary order halting any deportation or transfer of the pair while their case proceeds, citing concerns over child welfare[6].
Jan 27, 2026 – Judge Biery also blocks the removal, describing the raid as “essentially using a 5‑year‑old as bait” and condemning the Trump‑era “daily deportation quotas” as “ill‑conceived”[15][15].
Jan 27, 2026 – Rep. Joaquin Castro calls Liam “emblematic of the monstrosity of the ICE system” and announces a visit to Dilley with Rep. Jasmine Crockett[15].
Jan 27, 2026 – White House deputy chief of staff Stephen Miller notes the administration’s goal of 3,000 daily immigration arrests, a target the judge calls a “quota”[14].
Jan 27, 2026 – A lawsuit names DHS Secretary Kristi Noem and U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi as defendants, seeking relief from removal proceedings[6].
Jan 31, 2026 – Judge Fred Biery orders the immediate release of Liam and his father from Dilley, condemning the “perfidious lust for unbridled power” behind deportation quotas and setting a deadline of Feb 3 for compliance[1][14].
Jan 31, 2026 – The ruling notes the family entered the U.S. in December 2024, filed an asylum claim, and has no criminal record, underscoring the legal basis for release[4].
Jan 31, 2026 – The White House senior policy official Stephen Miller reiterates the 3,000‑arrest target, while the Trump administration signals intent to appeal the release order[14][4].
Feb 1, 2026 – Congressman Joaquin Castro personally escorts Liam and his father back to Minnesota, posting images of the reunion and noting the child’s “very depressed” condition during detention[9][5].
Feb 1, 2026 – Judge Biery’s opinion cites the Declaration of Independence, biblical verses, and Benjamin Franklin to denounce the “ill‑conceived… deportation quotas,” framing the case as a constitutional breach[5].
Feb 1, 2026 – Vice‑President JD Vance defends ICE, saying the agency “had no choice because the father ran,” while Rep. Ilhan Omar thanks Castro for bringing the family home[1].
Feb 2, 2026 – Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche announces the government will review options and likely appeal the release, warning that appellate courts may need to resolve the “schism in the law” over immigration detention[4].
Feb 2, 2026 – Governor Tim Walz tweets that “it should not take a court order to get a toddler out of a prison,” echoing calls for systemic reform[4].
Feb 2, 2026 – Adrian Conejo Arias denies abandoning his son, stating he “loves his 5‑year‑old” and that Liam fell ill and was denied medication at the Texas facility[12].
Feb 2, 2026 – Judge Jia Cobb issues a temporary restraining order blocking a new seven‑day notice rule that barred members of Congress from visiting ICE facilities, after 13 lawmakers challenge the policy[12].
Feb 2, 2026 – Senator Amy Klobuchar posts that the child “should be in school and with family—not in detention,” while Rep. Ilhan Omar shares a welcome‑home photo, underscoring bipartisan criticism[13].
Feb 2, 2026 – The family’s asylum case remains pending; Ecuadorian asylum seekers receive approvals in only 12.5 % of cases through September, highlighting the broader challenges they face[13].
Dive deeper (17 sub-stories)
-
AP: Father of detained 5‑year‑old disputes abandonment claims
-
CNN: Judge Frees 5‑Year‑Old Liam Ramos and Father After Texas Detention
-
AP: Minnesota Boy and Father Freed from Texas ICE Detention
-
BBC: Boy and Father Detained by ICE Return Home After Judge Orders Release
-
CNN: 5‑Year‑Old Liam Ramos and Father Released From Texas ICE Detention
-
Newsweek: 5‑Year‑Old Liam Ramos and Father Released After ICE Detention
-
King5 (Seattle, WA): Judge Orders Release of 5‑Year‑Old Boy and Father from Texas ICE Facility
-
Judge Fred Biery Orders Immediate Release of Ecuadorian Father and Son From Texas Detention
(2 articles)
-
BBC: Judge Orders Release of Five‑Year‑Old Detained by ICE in Minneapolis
-
AP: Judge orders release of detained 5‑year‑old and father in Texas
-
AP: Judge Blocks Deportation of Detained Ecuadorian Boy and Father
-
AP: Immigrant families protest Texas detention of Ecuadorian boy and father
-
AP: Detention of 5‑Year‑Old Boy and Father Sparks Conflicting Accounts
-
CNN: Minnesota preschooler detained by ICE sparks district-wide concern
-
Newsweek: Trump officials say 5-year-old Liam Ramos is with his family at an ICE facility
-
CNN: 5-year-old taken by ICE in Minneapolis area held with father at Texas facility
-
ICE Raid Detains Five‑Year‑Old Liam Ramos and Father in Minnesota, Sparking Community Outcry
(2 articles)
All related articles (19 articles)
-
AP: Father of detained 5‑year‑old disputes abandonment claims
-
CNN: Judge Frees 5‑Year‑Old Liam Ramos and Father After Texas Detention
-
AP: Minnesota Boy and Father Freed from Texas ICE Detention
-
BBC: Boy and Father Detained by ICE Return Home After Judge Orders Release
-
CNN: 5‑Year‑Old Liam Ramos and Father Released From Texas ICE Detention
-
Newsweek: 5‑Year‑Old Liam Ramos and Father Released After ICE Detention
-
King5 (Seattle, WA): Judge Orders Release of 5‑Year‑Old Boy and Father from Texas ICE Facility
-
Newsweek: Judge Orders Release of Ecuadorian Father and 5‑Year‑Old Son Detained by ICE
-
BBC: Judge Orders Release of Five‑Year‑Old Detained by ICE in Minneapolis
-
AP: Judge orders release of detained 5‑year‑old and father in Texas
-
AP: Judge Blocks Deportation of Detained Ecuadorian Boy and Father
-
CNN: Federal Judge Halts Deportation of Minnesota Preschooler and Father
-
AP: Immigrant families protest Texas detention of Ecuadorian boy and father
-
AP: Detention of 5‑Year‑Old Boy and Father Sparks Conflicting Accounts
-
CNN: Minnesota preschooler detained by ICE sparks district-wide concern
-
Newsweek: Trump officials say 5-year-old Liam Ramos is with his family at an ICE facility
-
CNN: 5-year-old taken by ICE in Minneapolis area held with father at Texas facility
-
AP: 5-year-old detained with father in Minnesota immigration raid
-
BBC: ICE detains five-year-old and father in Minnesota, lawyer says
External resources (12 links)
- https://x.com/DHSgov/status/2014412116409671814 (cited 2 times)
- https://x.com/DHSgov/status/2014701768551145831 (cited 2 times)
- https://x.com/GovTimWalz/status/2017709767599255694?s=20 (cited 2 times)
- https://x.com/ICEgov/status/2014358760630735012?s=20 (cited 2 times)
- https://x.com/JoaquinCastrotx/status/2017711364530442435?s=20 (cited 1 times)
- https://x.com/JoaquinCastrotx/status/2017984200444412025 (cited 1 times)
- https://x.com/TriciaOhio/status/2014498246710657511?s=20 (cited 1 times)
- https://x.com/dhsgov/status/2014322865848406370?s=46&t=Su4BjUkyoA25AmRM4RlgOg (cited 1 times)
- https://x.com/peggyflanagan/status/2017705910789906551?s=20 (cited 1 times)
- https://acrobat.adobe.com/id/urn:aaid:sc:VA6C2:ccd807d9-0321-471b-a27d-a8620ea97813 (cited 2 times)
- https://acrobat.adobe.com/id/urn:aaid:sc:VA6C2:ccd807d9-0321-471b-a27d-a8620ea97813?viewer%21megaVerb=group-discover (cited 2 times)
- https://www.expressnews.com/news/article/judge-5-year-old-migrant-released-texas-ice-21320852.php?utm_source=marketing&utm_medium=copy-url-link&utm_campaign=article-share&hash=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZXhwcmVzc25ld3MuY29tL25ld3MvYXJ0aWNsZS9qdWRnZS01LXllYXItb2xkLW1pZ3JhbnQtcmVsZWFzZWQtdGV4YXMtaWNlLTIxMzIwODUyLnBocA%3D%3D&time=MTc2OTg4NTA5NTg4Mg%3D%3D&rid=NzJjM2I3M2UtNWVhOS00Yjk5LWI0NDgtYTc4NzUyODY3MGQy&sharecount=MQ%3D%3D (cited 1 times)