Trump’s “No Guns at Protests” Claim Escalates Rift With Weakened NRA
Updated (10 articles)
President Trump publicly bans guns at protests, citing Pretti’s magazines On February 1, Trump told reporters “you can’t have guns…you can’t walk in with guns,” condemning the concealed‑carry permit holder Alex Pretti, who was killed by Border Patrol agents during a Minneapolis immigration protest. He added that Pretti’s two fully loaded magazines were “a lot of bad stuff” and framed the incident as a justification for restricting firearms at demonstrations [5][1]. The comment triggered immediate backlash from gun‑rights organizations that argue the Second Amendment protects lawful carry even at protests [5][6].
Multiple agencies and officials label Pretti an armed threat despite video evidence Federal officials, including DHS Secretary Kristi Noem and FBI Director Kash Patel, asserted that Pretti approached officers with a loaded handgun, prompting “defensive shots.” A Border Patrol memo later identified a Glock 19 and a Glock 47 used by agents, and agents shouted “He’s got a gun!” before the shooting [4][8]. However, by‑stander recordings released after the incident show Pretti holding a cellphone, assisting a pepper‑sprayed protester, and never drawing his weapon before agents seized his handgun [6][8][9].
NRA defends law‑abiding owners while criticizing prosecutor’s warning The NRA posted on X that “all law‑abiding citizens have a right to keep and bear arms anywhere they have a legal right to be,” directly countering Trump’s blanket ban [4][5][9]. It also denounced U.S. Attorney Bill Essayli’s statement that approaching police with a gun “makes it likely they will be legally justified in shooting you,” labeling the comment “dangerous and wrong” [5][9][10]. The organization remained silent on Trump’s specific remarks but emphasized protection of lawful gun owners [1].
NRA’s political clout continues to shrink amid internal turmoil After the 2024 resignation of President Wayne LaPierre and scandals, the NRA’s independent‑expenditure spending fell from over $30 million in the 2016 cycle to roughly $10 million in 2024 [1]. Despite reduced funding, the group still mobilizes opposition to policies it views as infringing gun rights, such as the Justice Department’s review of transgender firearm purchase restrictions, which the NRA opposed alongside the Human Rights Campaign [1]. The organization’s diminished influence contrasts with its historically pivotal role in shaping Republican gun policy.
The Pretti shooting fuels GOP intra‑party conflict ahead of 2026 midterms Republican lawmakers like Rep. Thomas Massie and Rep. Jeremy Faison defended the right to carry at protests, while others, including Trump officials, now advocate restrictions, exposing a split between the party’s law‑and‑order base and its traditional gun‑rights constituency [3][6][10]. The controversy also heightened the risk of a partial government shutdown, as Senate Democrats threatened to block DHS funding tied to the investigation [10]. Legal challenges from Minnesota officials seek to limit federal interference in the case, underscoring the escalating political stakes [7].
Sources
-
1.
CNN: Trump’s Gun‑Policy Rhetoric Collides With a Weakened NRA – Details Trump’s “no guns at protests” comment, NRA’s muted response, and the administration’s rollback of Biden gun rules, highlighting the NRA’s reduced spending and internal scandals .
-
2.
CNN: Trump officials reverse stance on guns at protests after Alex Pretti shooting – Describes the rapid policy shift by Trump, Noem, and Patel, contrasts with their 2020 praise for armed civilians, and notes criticism from gun‑rights groups .
-
3.
Newsweek: Trump’s Shift on Armed Protesters Sparks GOP Rift – Explores inconsistencies in Trump’s rhetoric, reactions from GOP lawmakers and left‑leaning leaders, and the midterm political implications .
-
4.
Newsweek: NRA Pushes Back After Trump Says “You Can’t Have Guns” – Reports NRA’s X statement defending law‑abiding owners, Patel’s warning on loaded firearms, and Trump’s deployment of border czar Tom Homan .
-
5.
CNN: Trump says “you can’t have guns” at protests, prompting gun‑rights backlash – Chronicles the administration’s initial gun‑focused defense, subsequent backlash from groups like GOA and NAGR, and officials’ claims linking the gun to Pretti’s intent .
-
6.
AP: Trump’s gun‑rights allies push back after Minnesota protester’s death – Highlights Pretti’s legal carry status, White House’s mixed messaging, and GOP lawmakers’ support for concealed‑carry reciprocity legislation .
-
7.
Newsweek: Militia Leader Warns Trump Tyranny Will Worsen After Alex Pretti Shooting – Features militia leader Virginia Kekoas’s condemnation, DHS statement, and legal actions by Minnesota officials to restrain federal investigation .
-
8.
Newsweek: NRA and Gun‑Rights Groups Call for Probe After Federal Agents Kill Minnesota Nurse – Emphasizes demands for a full investigation, video analysis showing agents removed Pretti’s gun before shooting, and partisan survey data on gun attitudes .
-
9.
BBC: NRA and gun groups demand Trump‑admin probe of Minneapolis shooting – Reports NRA’s call for investigation, contrast between administration’s armed‑threat claim and lack of video evidence, and criticism of prosecutor Essayli’s warning .
-
10.
Newsweek: Massie Defends Gun Rights After Alex Pretti Shooting Sparks Shutdown Threat – Details Rep. Thomas Massie’s defense of constitutional carry, Essayli’s warning, and the heightened shutdown risk tied to DHS funding disputes .
Videos (2)
Timeline
2018 – President Trump proposes stronger background‑check laws and a higher minimum purchase age after the Parkland shooting, but the NRA’s objections force him to withdraw the measures, marking the first major policy clash between the administration and the gun lobby[2].
2020 – Trump publicly praises Kyle Rittenhouse and the McCloskeys for brandishing firearms at protests, framing armed civilians as “patriots” and cementing his reputation as a defender of gun‑rights activists[3][5].
2023 – A Pew Research poll finds 79 % of Republicans say gun ownership makes communities safer, highlighting the partisan divide that later fuels the response to the Pretti shooting[8].
2024 – Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem lauds “hundreds of Second Amendment‑loving bikers” who openly carry guns at a Black Lives Matter protest in Sioux Falls, reinforcing GOP support for open‑carry at demonstrations[3].
2024 – Internal scandals lead to the resignation of NRA President Wayne LaPierre, and the organization’s independent‑expenditure spending drops from over $30 million in 2016 to $10 million in 2024, signaling a weakened political clout[2].
2025 – A Washington Post/Schar School poll reports that nearly nine‑in‑ten Republicans favor deploying federal troops to quell protests, underscoring the growing appetite for aggressive law‑enforcement responses[8].
Jan 24, 2026 – Federal Border Patrol agents fatally shoot ICU nurse Alex Pretti, a lawful concealed‑carry permit holder, during an immigration‑enforcement operation in Minneapolis; video later shows agents removing his handgun before firing[4][9].
Jan 25, 2026 – U.S. Attorney Bill Essayli warns on X that “if you approach law enforcement with a gun, there is a high likelihood they will be legally justified in shooting you,” prompting NRA condemnation as “dangerous and wrong” and a surge in shutdown betting as Senate Democrats threaten to block DHS funding[1][9].
Jan 25, 2026 – Rep. Thomas Massie defends the Second Amendment on X, calling the right to carry “a Constitutionally protected God‑given right,” while Minnesota Governor Tim Walz denounces the federal narrative as “nonsense” and “lies”[9][1].
Jan 26, 2026 – The NRA and Gun Owners of America demand a full investigation into Pretti’s death, emphasizing that his concealed‑carry permit made the carry legal and that the incident “does not constitute a crime” under Minnesota law[8].
Jan 26, 2026 – Video analysis confirms agents disarmed Pretti before the fatal shots, contradicting officials’ claims that he brandished a weapon and challenging the administration’s justification for the use of force[8].
Jan 27, 2026 – President Trump tells reporters, “You can’t have guns. You can’t walk in with guns. It’s a very unfortunate thing,” echoing a new administration stance that opposes armed protesters despite his earlier praise for armed civilians[4][6].
Jan 27, 2026 – Militia leader Virginia Kekoas (known as “ICE”) denounces the administration’s narrative as tyrannical, warning that “tyranny will only worsen with time” in response to the Pretti shooting[7].
Jan 27, 2026 – DHS releases an image of an alleged gun belonging to Pretti and Secretary Kristi Noem asserts agents fired “defensive shots” while attempting to disarm him, reinforcing the federal self‑defence claim[1].
Jan 28, 2026 – Trump repeats his “you can’t have guns” comment in Iowa, while White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt reiterates support for the Second Amendment but warns that bearing arms near police “raises the risk of force”[5][10].
Jan 28, 2026 – FBI Director Kash Patel tells Fox News viewers that “no one who wants to be peaceful shows up at a protest with a firearm that is loaded with two full magazines,” prompting backlash from gun‑rights groups such as the National Association for Gun Rights[6].
Jan 28, 2026 – Trump dispatches his immigration “czar” Tom Homan to Minnesota to meet state officials, signaling a federal focus on the investigation and an attempt to manage the political fallout[6].
Jan 28, 2026 – The House advances a concealed‑carry reciprocity bill that would make state permits mutually recognized nationwide, a legislative effort that could be reshaped by the controversy over Pretti’s death[10].
Jan 31, 2026 – If Congress fails to pass a DHS funding package, a partial government shutdown looms, with betting odds rising after the Pretti shooting heightened partisan tensions[9].
2026 midterms (Nov 2026) – Republicans eye the fallout from the Pretti case as a litmus test for their “law‑and‑order” base, while Democrats leverage the incident to criticize the administration’s handling of gun‑rights and immigration enforcement[5].
2026 (ongoing) – The Justice Department continues its review of proposed transgender gun‑purchase restrictions, facing opposition from both the NRA and the Human Rights Campaign, indicating broader battles over firearm regulations beyond the Pretti case[2].
External resources (21 links)
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4zRMVdGYgBw (cited 1 times)
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aegfqeklatY (cited 1 times)
- https://dps.mn.gov/divisions/bca/public-services-bca/firearms-information/permit-carry (cited 1 times)
- https://trumpwhitehouse.archives.gov/briefings-statements/remarks-president-trump-press-briefing-august-8-31-2020/ (cited 1 times)
- https://www.reuters.com/fact-check/us-capitol-attack-rioters-had-weapons-including-firearms-2025-01-16/ (cited 1 times)
- https://t.co/pbJNzU1E2P (cited 1 times)
- https://truthsocial.com/@realDonaldTrump/posts/115951636521315703 (cited 1 times)
- https://x.com/DHSgov/status/2015115351797780500 (cited 1 times)
- https://x.com/GavinNewsom/status/2015475599075385766 (cited 1 times)
- https://x.com/GunOwners/status/2016250470835036504?s=20 (cited 1 times)
- https://x.com/NRA/status/2015227627464728661 (cited 1 times)
- https://x.com/mccloskeyusa/status/2015386017176441104 (cited 1 times)
- https://x.com/mccloskeyusa/status/2015764141323993412 (cited 1 times)
- https://giffords.org/lawcenter/state-laws/open-carry-in-wisconsin/ (cited 2 times)
- https://imgur.com/ZJVgiqP (cited 1 times)
- https://rumble.com/vpi004-rittenhouse-railroaded-kyle-is-not-on-trial-the-second-amendment-is.html (cited 1 times)
- https://thereload.com/gun-rights-groups-chafe-at-dc-takeover-tactics-gun-arrests/ (cited 1 times)
- https://www.aberdeennews.com/story/opinion/columns/2021/04/09/noem-second-amendment-rights-cannot-be-infringed/43730785/ (cited 1 times)
- https://www.factcheck.org/2026/01/patels-remarks-conflict-with-minnesota-gun-law/ (cited 1 times)
- https://www.opensecrets.org/news/2017/11/audit-shows-nra-spending-surged-100-million-amidst-pro-trump-push-in-2016/ (cited 1 times)
- https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/national-rifle-assn/summary?topnumcycle=2024&toprecipcycle=2024&contribcycle=2024&lobcycle=2024&id=d000000082&outspendcycle=2016 (cited 1 times)