Supreme Court Set to Decide Trump Toy Tariff Case, Industry Awaits Outcome
Updated (3 articles)
Court Hearing Scheduled for Early February 2026 The Supreme Court announced it could issue a ruling on the Learning Resources lawsuit as early as Friday, February 21, 2026, ending weeks of uncertainty for manufacturers and retailers alike [1]. The case challenges the 2022 import tariffs imposed by former President Donald Trump on Chinese‑made toys, a policy that has reshaped supply‑chain calculations across the sector. A decision this week would determine whether firms can seek refunds for duties collected since the tariffs took effect.
Tariff Levels Dropped From Peak to Around Twenty Percent Tariffs on Chinese toys surged to a maximum of 145 % during 2025, forcing many companies to absorb or pass on costs [1]. By early 2026 the average duty settled near 20 %, a substantial reduction but still higher than pre‑Trump rates. The lower average has allowed some firms to moderate price hikes, though the legacy of the peak levy continues to influence sourcing strategies.
Toy Makers Report Price Increases and Profit Declines Basic Fun disclosed a 65 % drop in profit and raised its Tonka truck price from $30 to $35, a hike it plans to maintain through the end of 2026 [1]. Glo Pals increased its light‑up cube price by roughly 20 % to $12.99 after six years of stable pricing, citing the lingering impact of the tariff regime. Both companies attribute the moves to higher input costs and the need to preserve margins amid volatile trade conditions.
Industry Leaders Hope Ruling Could Trigger Refunds Learning Resources CEO Rick Woldenberg said visitors at the New York Toy Fair thanked his firm for “standing up,” reflecting broader industry support for the lawsuit [1]. Executives such as Jay Foreman of Basic Fun and Anna Barker of Glo Pals warned that the sector will remain “on edge” for at least three years, hoping a favorable decision will unlock billions in potential refunds. Harvard economist Alberto Cavallo noted that while cheaper toys saw faster price growth, the overall effect on toy prices has been modest.
Related Tickers
Timeline
2022 – Former President Donald Trump imposes import tariffs on Chinese‑made toys, a policy that later spikes to a 145 % peak rate in 2025 and fuels industry lawsuits challenging the duty structure [1][2].
Dec 7, 2025 – The National Retail Federation projects U.S. holiday sales to reach $1.01‑$1.02 trillion, a 3.7‑4.2 % year‑over‑year gain that signals robust consumer demand despite rising toy costs [3].
Dec 15, 2025 – Tariffs create uneven holiday price impacts: toy wholesale costs climb 5‑20 %, a $20‑$25 doll now sells for $30‑$35, small retailers such as Ah Louis Store trim assortments to higher‑margin items, and shoppers cut holiday gift budgets by $229 on average [2].
Feb 19, 2026 – The Supreme Court prepares to rule on Learning Resources’ challenge to the Trump‑era tariffs as early as Friday, a decision that could trigger refunds of billions and end years of trade‑cost uncertainty for the toy sector [1].
Feb 19, 2026 – Learning Resources CEO Rick Woldenberg says visitors at the New York Toy Fair thank his firm for “standing up,” reflecting broad industry support for overturning the tariffs [1].
Feb 19, 2026 – Harvard economist Alberto Cavallo observes that, although duties push up costs for cheaper toys faster, the overall effect on consumer toy prices is “little,” indicating a modest inflationary impact [1].
Feb 19, 2026 – Basic Fun lifts its Tonka truck price from $30 to $35 and plans to keep it through 2026, while Glo Pals raises its light‑up cubes to $12.99 after six years of stable pricing, illustrating immediate cost‑pass‑through to shoppers [1].
Feb 19, 2026 – Executives Jay Foreman (Basic Fun) and Anna Barker (Glo Pals) warn the sector will stay “on edge” for at least three years, hoping a favorable court outcome restores pricing stability and refunds collected under the tariff regime [1].