Seized Range Rover Leads Investigation as DNA Dead‑End Prompts Genealogy Push
Updated (7 articles)
Seized Range Rover Provides Primary Physical Evidence Investigators towed a gray Range Rover from near Nancy Guthrie’s Tucson home on Feb 13, covering it with a tarp to preserve potential evidence, and former FBI agent Jennifer Coffindaffer called the vehicle “Number One” lead in the case [1].
DNA Analysis Yields No CODIS Matches, Prompting Genealogy DNA from gloves recovered two miles from the home failed to match any of the 19 million profiles in CODIS, leading the Pima County Sheriff’s Department and the FBI to turn to investigative genetic genealogy databases for distant relative matches [1][2][3][4][5].
Surveillance Footage Identifies Masked Suspect and Backpack Doorbell‑camera video released Feb 10 shows a ski‑masked man about 5 ft 9‑10 in tall, wearing gloves, a waist‑holster, and a 25‑liter black Ozark Trail Hiker Pack; detectives have contacted Walmart to trace the backpack’s purchase [1][2][4][5].
Rewards Increased to $100,000 and Public Appeals Continue A private benefactor, the Pima County Sheriff’s Department, and the FBI each now offer $100,000 for information, while Savannah Guthrie posted an Instagram video urging anyone with tips to call 1‑800‑CALL‑FBI or submit them at tips.fbi.gov [2][4].
Family Cleared, Multi‑Person Theory Remains Open Sheriff Chris Nanos confirmed that Guthrie’s relatives are not suspects but said investigators have not ruled out involvement of more than one individual [1][4].
Sources
-
1.
Newsweek: Ex‑FBI Agent Calls Seized Range Rover “Number One” Lead in Nancy Guthrie Case: Highlights the Range Rover seizure as the most significant lead, details tarp handling, and notes family cleared and multi‑person scenario .
-
2.
CNN: New Evidence and $100,000 Rewards in Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping Case: Reports on doorbell footage, unusual holster, DNA dead‑end, ransom‑note confusion, and $100,000 rewards from private and law‑enforcement sources .
-
3.
CNN: Genetic Genealogy Becomes Central Tool in Nancy Guthrie Investigation: Explains shift to investigative genetic genealogy after CODIS failures, outlines database limitations, and forecasts legal battles over broader access .
-
4.
BBC: Glove DNA Test Yields No CODIS Match in Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping: Confirms glove DNA no CODIS hit, describes suspect’s appearance, reward increase, and massive tip volume .
-
5.
AP: DNA from gloves near Nancy Guthrie’s home yields no CODIS matches: Details CODIS failure, genealogy pursuit, neighbor camera footage, and use of BlueFly scanner to locate Guthrie’s pacemaker .
Timeline
Nov 1980 – The murders of 23‑year‑old Lynn Vest and her 2½‑year‑old cousin Jeremy Pickens occur in Columbus, Ohio, leaving the case cold for decades until DNA advances enable a breakthrough [7].
Apr 1, 1987 – Rhonda Fisher is found strangled near Sedalia, Colorado; the case remains unsolved for nearly 40 years, highlighting the limits of earlier forensic methods [4].
2018 – Investigators use investigative genetic genealogy to identify the Golden State Killer, demonstrating the power of genealogy databases for cold‑case work [3].
2022 – Genetic genealogy leads to the conviction of Bryan Kohberger for the Idaho student murders, reinforcing the technique’s forensic impact [3].
Dec 3, 2025 – Douglas County investigators extract DNA from 1987 paper bags and match it to deceased serial killer Vincent Groves, solving the Rhonda Fisher murder and showcasing modern DNA tools [4].
Jan 24, 2026 – Ohio authorities announce that genetic genealogy has linked Charles Elliott to the 1980 Vest‑Pickens murders; they plan to exhume Elliott’s remains to confirm the match [7].
Feb 1‑16, 2026 – Tip line receives 28,000 calls, a 54 % increase over the prior year, while Savannah Guthrie urges “It is never too late to do the right thing” in an Instagram video [6].
Feb 10, 2026 – Pima County releases grainy Nest doorbell footage showing a ski‑masked man covering the camera, estimated at 5 ft 9‑10 in with an average build, wearing a black Ozark Trail backpack and an unusual waist holster [2].
Feb 13, 2026 – Police seize a gray Range Rover parked near the Guthrie home, tarp it before towing, and label it “Number One” lead, according to former FBI agent Jennifer Coffindaffer [5].
Feb 17, 2026 – DNA from gloves found two miles from Nancy Guthrie’s Tucson home enters CODIS and yields no matches, prompting investigators to turn to broader genealogy databases [6].
Feb 18, 2026 – Sheriff Chris Nanos confirms the glove DNA still lacks a CODIS hit and announces the department will submit the sample to investigative genetic‑genealogy services [1].
Feb 19, 2026 – The sheriff’s office officially adopts investigative genetic genealogy to analyze the glove DNA, citing successes such as the Golden State Killer and Kohberger cases [3].
Feb 20, 2026 – Law enforcement and a private donor each raise the reward for information to $100,000, and officials describe ransom notes as “uncertain in authenticity,” noting a separate false‑threat suspect [2].
Feb 21, 2026 – Coffindaffer reiterates that the seized Range Rover is the most significant piece of evidence, emphasizing that investigators preserve its interior for potential forensic material [5].
2026‑2027 (ongoing) – Investigators continue genetic‑genealogy analysis of the glove DNA, while DNA‑justice CEO CeCe Moore warns the Guthrie family’s request for broader database access will likely spark a “knock‑down, drag‑out fight” unless a warrant compels it [3].
All related articles (7 articles)
-
Newsweek: Ex‑FBI Agent Calls Seized Range Rover “Number One” Lead in Nancy Guthrie Case
-
CNN: New Evidence and $100,000 Rewards in Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping Case
-
CNN: Genetic Genealogy Becomes Central Tool in Nancy Guthrie Investigation
-
BBC: Glove DNA Test Yields No CODIS Match in Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping
-
AP: DNA from gloves near Nancy Guthrie’s home yields no CODIS matches
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): Ohio cold case solved: DNA links 1980 murders to suspect
-
CNN: DNA from 1987 Paper Bags Identifies Colorado Serial Killer Vincent Groves in Rhonda Fisher Murder
External resources (12 links)
- https://www.fbi.gov/wanted/kidnap/nancy-guthrie/@@download.pdf (cited 1 times)
- https://www.instagram.com/p/DUlnfdsEWAL/?hl=en (cited 1 times)
- https://x.com/FBIPhoenix/status/2022084453699350981 (cited 1 times)
- http://www.familytreedna.com/ (cited 1 times)
- https://88crime.org/pcso-nancy-guthrie/ (cited 1 times)
- https://dcsheriff.net/nearly-four-decades-later-the-1987-murder-of-rhonda-marie-fisher-has-been-solved/?fbclid=IwY2xjawOcTc9leHRuA2FlbQIxMABicmlkETF5eDdUcUY4Q0liOGJqeENFc3J0YwZhcHBfaWQQMjIyMDM5MTc4ODIwMDg5MgABHh2hiNdegxCSNuGsXbK40--0Y0df8NqSP-zJs6OjT2v2SbgQ04AU7R8CBycI_aem_h-b-MV3cQTrq3wujBhjaIg (cited 1 times)
- https://www.23andme.com/law-enforcement-guide/ (cited 1 times)
- https://www.23andme.com/transparency-report/ (cited 1 times)
- https://www.ancestry.com/c/legal/lawenforcement#:~:text=Ancestry%20does%20not%20voluntarily%20cooperate,or%20to%20identify%20human%20remains. (cited 1 times)
- https://www.dnajustice.org/ (cited 1 times)
- https://www.gedmatch.com/ (cited 1 times)
- https://www.myheritage.com/privacy-policy (cited 1 times)