New Eyewitness Death Revives Calls for Independent Probe of 2025 ICE Shooting
Updated (17 articles)
March 15 2025 Traffic Stop Ends in Fatal Shooting On South Padre Island, Texas, 23‑year‑old U.S. citizen Ruben Ray Martinez was directing traffic with Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) agents after a multi‑vehicle crash when his blue Ford accelerated, struck an HSI special agent on the hood, and prompted a supervisory agent to fire multiple rounds through the driver’s side window, killing Martinez and injuring the first agent’s knee; he was pronounced dead at a Brownsville hospital while the passenger was taken into custody[2][8]. DHS initially described the fire as defensive, later confirming ICE involvement through FOIA‑released internal reports, marking the first documented killing of a U.S. citizen by a federal immigration officer during the Trump‑era crackdown[3][7]. No body‑camera or dash‑cam footage has been released, and the agents’ positioning in front of a moving vehicle has been widely criticized by use‑of‑force scholars[8][9].
Texas Rangers Lead Ongoing State Investigation The Texas Department of Public Safety’s Ranger Division assumed primary investigative authority shortly after the shooting and completed a state report in October 2025, which is slated for grand‑jury review to determine possible criminal charges[9][11]. Federal agencies, including the FBI’s San Antonio office, have declined participation, leaving the investigation under state jurisdiction[3][5]. DHS continues to label the case “active” but directs inquiries to the Rangers, while simultaneously announcing a rollout of body‑cameras for field agents in response to criticism over missing footage[1][5].
Family, Attorneys, and Lawmakers Demand Full Accountability Martinez’s mother, Rachel Reyes, and attorneys Charles M. Stam and Alex Stamm have repeatedly called for a transparent, independent inquiry, citing video evidence that they say contradicts the federal narrative[7][8]. Texas Democratic Representative Joaquin Castro, State Senator Roland Gutierrez, Representative Greg Casar, and other officials have accused DHS of an eight‑month cover‑up and urged congressional investigations[5][1]. San Antonio Mayor Gina Ortiz Jones also petitioned Congress to open a probe, emphasizing the need for answers after a year of silence[2].
Eyewitness Joshua Orta’s Fatal Crash Revives Investigation Pressure Joshua Orta, the 25‑year‑old sole eyewitness who planned to submit a sworn statement describing the shooting as “spontaneous” and alleging multiple close‑range shots, handcuffing, and a ten‑minute CPR delay, died in a highway crash near San Antonio on February 24 2026, eliminating his anticipated testimony[1]. Orta’s account, which contradicted DHS’s defensive‑fire claim, has intensified demands for a new probe and for the release of any existing body‑camera footage[1][5]. The incident has prompted DHS to accelerate its body‑camera rollout, a policy shift highlighted after similar controversies in Minneapolis[1].
Sources
-
1.
Newsweek: Eyewitness to ICE Shooting of Ruben Ray Martinez Killed in Separate Crash, Raising Calls for New Investigation: Reports Orta’s planned contradictory statement, his fatal crash, and renewed calls for investigation, noting DHS’s body‑camera rollout.
-
2.
Newsweek: San Antonio Mayor Calls for Congressional Probe into 2025 HSI Shooting of Ruben Ray Martinez: Details Mayor Gina Ortiz Jones’s request for a congressional inquiry and outlines DHS’s defensive‑fire narrative.
-
3.
Newsweek: DHS Confirms Third U.S. Citizen Killing After Newsweek Investigation: Confirms ICE involvement via FOIA documents, describes the March 2025 incident, and notes Texas Rangers leading the probe.
-
4.
Newsweek: Mother of U.S. Citizen Killed by ICE Agent Calls for Answers After Year‑Long Silence: Highlights Rachel Reyes’s demands for justice and criticism of delayed disclosure by DHS.
-
5.
Newsweek: ICE Agent’s Fatal Shooting of U.S. Citizen Ruben Ray Martinez Sparks Lawmaker Outcry: Covers congressional backlash, FOIA‑obtained ICE records, and lack of video evidence.
-
6.
Newsweek: Royal Arrest, ICE Shooting, and Rising US‑Iran Tensions Mark Week’s Wow Moments: Briefly mentions the ICE shooting as part of a roundup of notable events.
-
7.
Le Monde: U.S. Citizen Killed in 2025 Texas Shooting Revealed by FOIA Documents: Provides French‑language summary of FOIA findings, victim’s death, and upcoming grand‑jury review.
-
8.
CNN: Texas Citizen Killed by Federal Immigration Agent in 2025 Traffic Stop: Reports on the shooting, Texas Rangers’ investigation, and expert criticism of agent positioning.
-
9.
AP: Federal Immigration Agent Killed Texas Man in 2025 Traffic Shooting, Records Reveal: Details the incident, Texas Rangers’ role, and family’s demand for accountability.
-
10.
Newsweek: Newsom Criticizes Year‑Long Silence on ICE Fatal Shooting of Texas Citizen: Highlights Governor Gavin Newsom’s condemnation of DHS’s delayed disclosure and the case’s significance.
-
11.
Newsweek: ICE Agent’s Fatal Shooting of U.S. Citizen Ruben Ray Martinez Revealed: Announces ICE involvement, initial media omission, and ongoing state investigation.
Related Tickers
Timeline
Mar 15, 2025 – A Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) team redirects traffic after a multi‑injury crash on South Padre Island; driver Ruben Ray Martinez accelerates, runs over an HSI special agent on the hood, and a supervisory HSI agent fires multiple rounds through the driver’s side window, killing Martinez with three bullet wounds and injuring the agent’s knee, while DHS later frames the fire as “defensive” after an “intentional run‑over” [10][12][17].
Jan 7, 2025 – Federal agents fatally shoot Renée Good in Minneapolis, an incident later cited as a precedent for questioning HSI tactics in the Martinez case [1].
Jan 24, 2025 – Federal agents fatally shoot Alex Pretti in Minneapolis, adding to the series of deadly federal‑officer shootings that shape the national debate on immigration‑enforcement use of force [1].
2025 (throughout the year) – The Martinez killing becomes the earliest of at least six fatal officer incidents recorded since the nationwide immigration‑enforcement surge launched in President Trump’s second term, highlighting a shift of border‑task‑force agents to immigration duties [1].
Oct 2025 – The Texas Rangers complete a state investigative report on the Martinez shooting and schedule its presentation to a grand jury, signaling the next legal step in the case [1][12].
Jan 27, 2026 – In Arivaca, Arizona, a Border Patrol attempt to stop a pickup leads driver Patrick Gary Schlegel to fire at a CBP helicopter and agents; agents return fire, wounding Schlegel critically, and the FBI asks the Pima County Sheriff’s Department to lead a use‑of‑force investigation [2][11][13][15][16].
Jan 28, 2026 – Authorities confirm Schlegel faces federal charges of assault on a federal officer, alien smuggling, and felon‑in‑possession of a firearm; the incident marks the seventh Arizona law‑enforcement shooting in 2026 and follows two fatal Minnesota shootings earlier that month [11][13][15][16].
Feb 19, 2026 – FOIA‑obtained ICE records publicly reveal that an HSI officer fired the fatal shots at Martinez, correcting earlier local reports that omitted federal involvement and confirming the agent’s “defensive fire” claim [10][17].
Feb 20, 2026 – Governor Gavin Newsom’s office calls the nearly year‑long delay in disclosing the Martinez shooting “deeply concerning,” demanding transparency and accountability for DHS actions [9].
Feb 21, 2026 – DHS confirms the Martinez killing as the third known U.S.‑citizen death by a federal immigration agent, reiterates that the driver “intentionally ran over” an agent, and notes the Texas Department of Public Safety Rangers continue the “active” investigation [5][6][8].
Feb 21, 2026 – San Antonio Mayor Gina Ortiz Jones posts on X urging Congress to open a probe, stating “we need a full and fair investigation” into the March 2025 HSI shooting of Martinez [4].
Feb 22, 2026 – Mayor Ortiz Jones’s press release reiterates the call for a congressional inquiry, emphasizing that Martinez was a “23‑year‑old U.S. citizen celebrating his birthday” when he was shot [4].
Feb 24, 2026 – Eyewitness Joshua Orta dies in a highway crash; before his death he planned to submit a sworn statement contradicting DHS’s account, alleging the agents fired “multiple shots from a few feet away without warning” and delayed CPR for at least ten minutes [3].
Feb 2026 (later) – In response to criticism over missing body‑camera footage, DHS announces a rollout of body‑cameras for field agents, a policy shift intended to increase transparency in future use‑of‑force incidents [3].
2026 (upcoming) – Texas Rangers intend to present their October report to a grand jury, while congressional leaders—including Rep. Joaquin Castro and Sen. Roland Gutierrez—press for an independent federal investigation, setting the stage for potential legislative oversight of ICE’s lethal‑force protocols [4][6][8].
Dive deeper (4 sub-stories)
-
Death of Key Eyewitness Revives Calls for Fresh Probe into 2025 Texas ICE Shooting
(10 articles)
-
Newsweek: Royal Arrest, ICE Shooting, and Rising US‑Iran Tensions Mark Week’s Wow Moments
-
Border Patrol Agents Shoot Suspect Who Fired on Helicopter Near Arivaca, Arizona, Leaving Him Critical
(5 articles)
-
AP: FBI finds no surveillance video of Border Patrol shooting in Portland
All related articles (17 articles)
-
Newsweek: Eyewitness to ICE Shooting of Ruben Ray Martinez Killed in Separate Crash, Raising Calls for New Investigation
-
Newsweek: San Antonio Mayor Calls for Congressional Probe into 2025 HSI Shooting of Ruben Ray Martinez
-
Newsweek: DHS Confirms Third U.S. Citizen Killing After Newsweek Investigation
-
Newsweek: Mother of U.S. Citizen Killed by ICE Agent Calls for Answers After Year‑Long Silence
-
Newsweek: ICE Agent’s Fatal Shooting of U.S. Citizen Ruben Ray Martinez Sparks Lawmaker Outcry
-
Newsweek: Royal Arrest, ICE Shooting, and Rising US‑Iran Tensions Mark Week’s Wow Moments
-
Le Monde: U.S. Citizen Killed in 2025 Texas Shooting Revealed by FOIA Documents
-
CNN: Texas Citizen Killed by Federal Immigration Agent in 2025 Traffic Stop
-
AP: Federal Immigration Agent Killed Texas Man in 2025 Traffic Shooting, Records Reveal
-
Newsweek: Newsom Criticizes Year‑Long Silence on ICE Fatal Shooting of Texas Citizen
-
Newsweek: ICE Agent’s Fatal Shooting of U.S. Citizen Ruben Ray Martinez Revealed
-
Newsweek: Border Patrol Agent Shoots Suspect Near Arivaca, Arizona
-
AP: Man Wounded After Shooting at Border Patrol Helicopter Near Arivaca
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): Shooting Near Arivaca Leaves One Person Critical After Border Patrol Clash
-
King5 (Seattle, WA): Shooting Near Arivaca Leaves One Man in Critical Condition
-
CNN: Shooting Near Arizona Border Leaves One Person Critical
-
AP: FBI finds no surveillance video of Border Patrol shooting in Portland
External resources (6 links)
- https://www.nytimes.com/2026/02/23/us/ice-shooting-texas-witness-dead.html (cited 1 times)
- https://www.politico.com/news/2026/02/17/ice-officials-use-of-force-00782501 (cited 1 times)
- https://x.com/Mayor_GOJ/status/2025319436110934267?s=20 (cited 2 times)