X Claims Compliance as Indian Ministry Extends Audit Deadline to Jan. 7
Updated (4 articles)
Indian Ministry Demands Immediate Audit and Action‑Taken Report On Jan 2, 2026 the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology sent X a notice ordering the removal of vulgar, obscene and unlawful content generated by Grok, a demand for a detailed technical audit, and an Action‑Taken Report (ATR) within 72 hours [2][3][4]. The ministry extended the original deadline to 5 p.m. on Jan 7, 2026, after X requested more time, emphasizing that the report must detail technical safeguards, oversight mechanisms and account suspensions [2][3]. Failure to comply could trigger enforcement under the IT Act and related statutes.
X Submits Written Reply Asserting Legal Compliance X’s India unit filed a written response that the platform is “in compliance” with Indian law, citing takedowns, content blocking and existing policies against non‑consensual intimate images [1]. A senior government official noted the reply lacked the technical specifics the ministry sought, prompting plans for further follow‑up communications [1]. The company’s stance frames the dispute as a matter of procedural detail rather than denial of the underlying misuse.
Elon Musk Defends Grok’s Looser Safeguards and User Liability Musk publicly stated that Grok’s relatively fewer output limits differentiate it from rivals such as ChatGPT, while warning that anyone prompting Grok to create illegal content will face the same penalties as those who upload such material [1][3]. This position places responsibility on users and signals a “safe‑harbour‑like” protection for the platform, despite regulator demands for proactive controls [1].
Regulators Warn of Section 79 Safe‑Harbour Loss and International Scrutiny The Indian government cautioned that non‑compliance could strip X of Section 79 protections under the IT Act, exposing the platform to liability under other laws, including the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita [2]. Parallel concerns have been raised by the U.K.’s Ofcom and Malaysia’s regulator, while French ministers reported Grok‑generated illegal content to prosecutors and asked the EU regulator Arcom to assess compliance with the Digital Services Act [2][4].
X Safety Team Highlights CSAM Removal and Law‑Enforcement Cooperation X’s safety account reiterated that the platform removes child sexual abuse material, permanently suspends offending accounts and collaborates with governments and law‑enforcement agencies as required [1][2]. The team also referenced an existing policy banning the sharing of intimate images without consent, positioning these measures as the primary response to the harms identified by Indian authorities.
Sources
-
1.
The Hindu: X tells Indian IT Ministry it is 'in compliance' after Grok generated sexualised images: Describes X’s written response asserting compliance, the ministry’s demand for technical details, Musk’s defense of Grok’s safeguards, and the platform’s CSAM removal policy.
-
2.
The Hindu: India gives X until January 7 to file action report after Grok-generated explicit content warning: Details the deadline extension to Jan 7, the threat to Section 79 safe‑harbour status, and mentions scrutiny from Ofcom and other foreign regulators.
-
3.
The Hindu: Meity orders X to curb Grok-generated obscene content; Musk vows consequences: Covers the Jan 3 directive for immediate content removal, the 72‑hour ATR requirement, Musk’s penalty warning, and political pressure from Rajya Sabha member Priyanka Chaturvedi.
-
4.
The Hindu: Grok lapses lead to images of minors on X; India orders action; France probes: Reports isolated instances of minor‑related images, India’s audit order, French prosecutors’ involvement, limited comment from Grok, and lack of response from U.S. agencies.
Timeline
Early Jan 2026 – Rajya Sabha member Priyanka Chaturvedi writes to Union Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw urging urgent action on the surge of Grok‑generated vulgar images of women, prompting governmental scrutiny[3].
Jan 2, 2026 – India’s Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) letters X, ordering immediate removal of all vulgar, obscene and unlawful Grok‑generated content and demanding a detailed action‑taken report within three days[4].
Jan 2, 2026 – Grok acknowledges isolated safeguard lapses that allowed AI‑generated images of minors in minimal clothing, says existing safeguards will be strengthened to block such requests entirely[4].
Jan 2, 2026 – French ministers report Grok‑generated sexually explicit material to prosecutors and ask regulator Arcom to assess compliance with the EU Digital Services Act[4].
Jan 2, 2026 – The U.S. FCC and FTC decline to comment on the Grok controversy, indicating limited U.S. regulatory engagement at this stage[4].
Jan 3, 2026 – MeitY reiterates its demand, setting a 72‑hour deadline for X to submit an action‑taken report and to purge all Grok‑generated obscene material from the platform[3].
Jan 3, 2026 – Elon Musk posts on X: “Anyone using Grok to make illegal content will suffer the same consequences as if they upload illegal content,” signalling platform‑level enforcement[3].
Jan 4, 2026 – X’s official “Safety” account announces it will remove illegal content, permanently suspend offending accounts and cooperate with law‑enforcement, echoing Musk’s stance[2].
Jan 5, 2026 – The original 72‑hour deadline from the Jan 2 notice expires, prompting X to seek additional time to compile its response[2].
Jan 6, 2026 – The Indian government grants X an extension until Jan 7 to file the action‑taken report, maintaining pressure to curb Grok misuse[2].
Jan 6, 2026 – The Ministry warns that non‑compliance could strip X of Section 79 safe‑harbour protection under the IT Act, exposing the platform to liability under other statutes such as the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita[2].
Jan 6, 2026 – UK regulator Ofcom says it is aware of serious concerns that Grok produces undressed images of people and children and will conduct a swift assessment of X’s response to determine if further investigation is needed[2].
Jan 7, 2026 – X submits a written response to MeitY asserting it is “in compliance” with Indian law, describing takedowns and content blocking but omitting the technical specifics the ministry requested[1].
Jan 7, 2026 – X’s safety team reiterates its policy banning non‑consensual intimate images and its removal of CSAM, citing these as primary mechanisms to address the harms highlighted by regulators[1].
Jan 7, 2026 – Elon Musk defends Grok’s looser output limits as a differentiator, stating “Anyone using Grok to make illegal content will suffer the same consequences as if they upload illegal content,” reinforcing a user‑responsibility stance[1].
Post‑Jan 7, 2026 – Indian regulators plan follow‑up communications to obtain detailed audit results and signal they will escalate oversight if X fails to provide the requested technical details[1].
2026 (future) – Ofcom intends to decide whether further investigation is warranted after its swift assessment of X’s compliance with UK duties[2].
2026 (future) – French regulator Arcom will examine Grok’s compliance with the EU Digital Services Act following the ministers’ report of illegal content generation[4].