Columbus Police Seek Public Video to Solve Hilltop Shooting of James Pettigrew
Updated (12 articles)
Incident Details Confirmed by Police Reports On January 27 2026, officers responded to a shooting at the 500 block of South Richardson Avenue in Columbus’s West Side Hilltop neighborhood. The victim was identified as 31‑year‑old James Pettigrew, who was found with a gunshot wound and pronounced dead at 3:53 p.m. after being taken to Grant Medical Center [1][2]. The incident occurred between 3:20 p.m. and 3:53 p.m., placing it squarely within the afternoon window investigators are examining.
Investigation Lacks Suspect or Motive Information Police have not released any details about a suspect, motive, or prior events leading to the shooting, emphasizing that the case remains open [1][2]. Detectives have repeatedly stated that no arrests have been made and that the investigation is ongoing. The lack of public suspect information has prompted authorities to broaden their outreach for community assistance.
Authorities Request Surveillance Footage From Defined Block Detectives are asking anyone with security or surveillance video captured between 3 p.m. and 5 p.m. on January 27 to submit it anonymously [1][2]. The area of interest is bounded by Fremont Street to the north, Springmont Avenue to the south, South Wayne Avenue to the east, and South Burgess Avenue to the west. Submissions can be made via a QR code, the Columbus Police Homicide Unit tip line (614‑645‑4730), or Central Ohio Crime Stoppers (614‑461‑TIPS) [1][2]. Police assure that all information will be kept confidential to encourage witnesses to come forward.
Family Expresses Grief and Calls for Community Support James Pettigrew’s sister, Martina Gibbs Dowdy, described the loss as “overwhelming,” while his mother, Jacqueline Saulsbery, referred to him as “my baby” and asked for prayers and justice [1]. The family, which includes two young children, has been dispersed across multiple states, intensifying the emotional impact. Community members are urged to assist the investigation to help bring closure to the grieving relatives.
Sources
-
1.
WBNS: Columbus police ask public’s help after 31‑year‑old James Pettigrew was shot dead in Hilltop – Feb 4 2026 article emphasizing police’s video request, family statements, and lack of suspect details
-
2.
WBNS: 31-Year-Old Man Killed in West Columbus Shooting – Jan 30 2026 article reporting the shooting’s basic facts, victim identification, and identical appeal for surveillance footage
Timeline
Nov 30, 2025 – Police respond after midnight to a shooting on Stelzer Road at the I‑670 on‑ramp near John Glenn International Airport, find a juvenile with a lower‑body gunshot wound who is taken to a hospital and expected to survive; investigators have not identified a suspect and ask the public for information (Detective Reffitt) [12].
Dec 6, 2025 – Homicide detectives investigate a non‑intentional shooting between family members at the 200 block of South Wheatland Avenue in Hilltop, where a juvenile suffers life‑threatening injuries and is hospitalized; no charges are filed and police request tips from the community [10].
Dec 7, 2025 – Officers arrive at the 2600 block of Osceola Avenue in North Linden shortly after 1 p.m., find a man with an apparent gunshot wound and pronounce him dead at the scene; homicide detectives launch an investigation with no suspect or motive disclosed and solicit public assistance [11].
Dec 23, 2025 – Columbus police respond to the 1500 block of East Long Street around 8:45 p.m., discover 2‑year‑old Va’Niyah Mason shot inside a home, pronounce her dead at 9:13 p.m.; the incident is classified as a non‑intentional shooting involving multiple occupants, and detectives seek information on how the firearm was accessed [9].
Jan 1, 2026 – Over roughly 12 hours, five separate shootings occur across west, southeast, and north Columbus, injuring seven people; incidents include a critical injury on Sullivant Ave, two victims at a New Year’s Eve party on South Hamilton Road, a multiple‑shot victim on North Fourth Street, two injured at an after‑hours club on Busch Boulevard, and a female wounded after a group argument on Laraine Court, with no suspects identified [7].
Jan 1, 2026 – Just before 1 a.m., police respond to a New Year’s Eve party in a warehouse at 2300 South Hamilton Road, find two victims—one in critical condition and one stable—and note that organizers marketed the event as “the best New Year’s,” while investigators have not released suspect information and request tips [8].
Jan 6, 2026 – Officers arrive at 11:35 p.m. to a business in the 2900 block of Hayden Road, find an adult shot dead inside; two individuals who identify themselves as the shooters are detained, claim self‑defense, and police probe a possible attempted robbery motive, while the homicide unit continues to seek public tips [6].
Jan 8, 2026 – Columbus police dispatch to the 1200 block of East Hudson Street at 3:45 p.m., find a victim shot in the face in a business parking lot, later stabilize; a possible suspect is detained, no juveniles are involved, and detectives ask the community for information [5].
Jan 11, 2026 – Officers respond to the 5900 block of South High Street around 11:05 p.m., find a person shot after a dispute in a business parking lot, transport the victim to Grant Medical Center where they die; the other adult cooperates, the case is sent to the Franklin County Prosecutor’s Office for review, and police solicit tips [4].
Jan 16, 2026 – Police arrive at 2:20 p.m. in the 2000 block of Nissi Drive near Agler Road, locate a juvenile with a gunshot wound who is taken to a hospital; investigators have no suspect or motive information and urge the public to provide tips to the Felony Assault Unit [3].
Jan 27, 2026 – At about 3:20 p.m., officers find 31‑year‑old James Pettigrew shot on South Richardson Avenue in Hilltop, pronounce him dead at 3:53 p.m.; detectives release no suspect or motive details, request security video from 3–5 p.m. within a defined block, and provide anonymous tip options [2].
Feb 4, 2026 – Columbus police issue a renewed public appeal for video and witnesses to the Hilltop shooting, highlighting family grief: sister Martina Gibbs Dowdy says the family is “overwhelmed” and mother Jacqueline Saulsbery calls her son “my baby,” while detectives continue to seek information and assure anonymity for tipsters [1].
Dive deeper (11 sub-stories)
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): Columbus police ask public’s help after 31‑year‑old James Pettigrew was shot dead in Hilltop
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): 31-Year-Old Man Killed in West Columbus Shooting
-
Juvenile Shot in Northeast Columbus Near Agler Road; Police Seek Suspect
(2 articles)
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): One dead after south Columbus shooting; investigation underway
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): One seriously injured in Linden shooting, suspect detained, investigation ongoing
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): One person fatally shot inside northwest Columbus business; police probe possible attempted robbery
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): Seven injured across five Columbus shootings over about 12 hours
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): Two injured in shooting at southeast Columbus New Year’s Eve party
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): 2-year-old girl dead after east Columbus shooting, police say non-intentional
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): Man Dead After North Linden Shooting in Columbus
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): Juvenile Shot Near John Glenn International Airport
All related articles (12 articles)
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): Columbus police ask public’s help after 31‑year‑old James Pettigrew was shot dead in Hilltop
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): 31-Year-Old Man Killed in West Columbus Shooting
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): Juvenile wounded in northeast Columbus shooting; no suspect information released
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): One dead after south Columbus shooting; investigation underway
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): One seriously injured in Linden shooting, suspect detained, investigation ongoing
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): One person fatally shot inside northwest Columbus business; police probe possible attempted robbery
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): Seven injured across five Columbus shootings over about 12 hours
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): Two injured in shooting at southeast Columbus New Year’s Eve party
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): 2-year-old girl dead after east Columbus shooting, police say non-intentional
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): Man Dead After North Linden Shooting in Columbus
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): Juvenile Seriously Injured in West Columbus Shooting — Homicide Unit Investigating
-
WBNS (Columbus, OH): Juvenile Shot Near John Glenn International Airport