Top Headlines

Feeds

Family Files Wrongful‑Death Suit Over Ignored Threats After 2024 Columbus Shooting

Updated (28 articles)
  • None
    None
    Image: WBNS (Columbus, OH)
    Credit: Columbus Division of Police Source Full size
  • None
    None
    Image: WBNS (Columbus, OH)
    Credit: Columbus Division of Police Source Full size

March 21 2024 Fatal Shooting Triggers Lawsuit The Freeman estate filed a wrongful‑death action in Franklin County Common Pleas Court alleging that three Columbus police officers failed to intervene before Marchelle Freeman was shot by her partner Stewart Butler on March 21, 2024 [1]. The suit claims officers ignored repeated threats reported by Freeman and Butler, violating duty to protect. The filing seeks accountability for the officers’ inaction.

Police Responded Twice but Did Not Seize Firearm Officers first arrived at Freeman’s residence around 6:24 p.m., spoke with both parties, and left without removing Butler’s gun [1]. After a second 9:16 p.m. call from Butler warning he might use the firearm, police returned but again failed to confiscate the weapon or arrest him. Butler presented paperwork from a prior municipal case ordering the gun’s forfeiture, which the complaint says should have prompted immediate seizure.

City Data Shows Domestic‑Violence Homicides Remain High Columbus officials reported that overall homicides fell last year, yet roughly 40 % of those deaths were linked to domestic violence [1]. The statistic underscores the city’s focus on domestic‑violence prevention despite broader crime declines. Police and city leaders cite the figure when discussing resource allocation and policy reforms.

Police Union Attributes Responsibility to Shooter Brian Steel, president of the Fraternal Order of Police Capital City Lodge No. 9, called the death “heartbreaking” but placed primary blame on Butler [1]. Steel noted that officers are trained to arrest primary aggressors and highlighted systemic challenges posed by repeat offenders. The union’s statement contrasts with the family’s claim of police negligence.

Jan 27 2026 West‑Side Shooting Prompts Public Appeal On January 27, 2026, detectives responded to a fatal shooting at about 3:20 p.m. in the 500 block of South Richardson Avenue, where James Pettigrew was found with a gunshot wound and pronounced dead at 3:53 p.m. [2]. Police announced four persons of interest, describing them as armed and dangerous, and urged community members to provide information.

Investigation Emphasizes Community Cooperation Officers requested any surveillance footage captured between 3 p.m. and 5 p.m. covering the block bounded by Fremont Street, Springmont Avenue, South Wayne Avenue, and South Burgess Avenue [2]. A QR code was provided for anonymous tip submissions, reflecting a strategy to involve residents in identifying the suspects.

Sources

Related Tickers

Timeline

July 28, 2024 – Officers respond to a gunfire report at Charley’s Place on Glenwood Avenue, find Jacob Coons dead and a second patron wounded; a pool‑hall dispute leads to Coons’ murder, and the suspect later flees [5].

March 21, 2024 – Marchelle Freeman calls police reporting threats from her partner Stewart Butler, who shows a court order to forfeit his gun; officers leave twice without seizing the weapon, and Butler later shoots Freeman, prompting a wrongful‑death suit that alleges missed arrests and firearm seizure [1].

April 14, 2024 – A ShotSpotter alert triggers a police response in North Linden; two hours later detectives find 13‑year‑old Angel Diaz dead, and later three men plead guilty to involuntary manslaughter, receiving 12‑21½ year sentences [3].

July 9, 2025 – Columbus police investigate a Target parking‑lot shooting near Polaris Parkway; 26‑year‑old Joseph Suiter dies, and later Elijah Roberts receives a life sentence with parole after 27 years, with Sgt. Joseph Albert noting the incident is unrelated to the Target store [13].

Nov 2, 2025 – A road‑rage dispute on East Hudson Street ends in a vehicle crash that kills 22‑year‑old Hannah Taylor; police later identify suspect Khaliq Hunt on Dec 4, issuing a murder warrant [24].

Nov 21, 2025 – Two separate shootings occur: 42‑year‑old Keith Morgan is killed on North Hampton Road, and 25‑year‑old Lamar Ross is murdered on North High Street; both cases lead to arrests—Tyrek Simpson on Dec 4 and Miyaira Tyler on Dec 5, who surrenders [26][25].

Nov 30, 2025 – Police find a juvenile shot near the I‑670 on‑ramp at John Glenn International Airport; the victim survives, but investigators have no suspect and request public tips [27].

Dec 4, 2025 – Tyrek Simpson is arrested in downtown Columbus on murder charges for the Nov 21 North High Street shooting; Sgt. James Fuqua says there is no public threat and calls the incident an isolated confrontation [26].

Dec 4, 2025 – Police publicly identify Khaliq Hunt as the suspect in the Nov 2 road‑rage murder of Hannah Taylor, issuing a statewide warrant [24].

Dec 5, 2025 – Miyaira Tyler turns herself in after being charged with murder for the Nov 21 North Hampton Road shooting; video evidence from the scene helped identify her [25].

Dec 6, 2025 – A juvenile is seriously injured in a West Columbus shooting on South Wheatland Avenue; police label the incident non‑intentional and seek information from the community [22].

Dec 7, 2025 – Officers respond to the 2600 block of Osceola Avenue in North Linden and find a man dead from a gunshot wound; detectives launch an active homicide investigation [23].

Dec 22, 2025 – Two‑year‑old Va’Niyah Mason is shot inside a home on East Long Street; police call the incident non‑intentional and accidental, prompting community shock and a grand‑jury indictment weeks later [20][21].

Dec 31 2025 – Jan 1 2026 – Five separate shootings occur across Columbus within 12 hours, including a critical injury on Sullivant Ave, two victims at a New Year’s Eve party on South Hamilton Rd, a multiple‑shot victim on North Fourth St, two injured at an after‑hours club on Busch Blvd, and a single‑shot wound on Laraine Ct; police seek video and tips for each incident [18][19].

Jan 2, 2026 – Columbus police respond to a Hilltop shooting on Sullivant Ave; investigators later rule the fatal wound self‑inflicted, and the victim’s identity remains unreleased [17].

Jan 6, 2026 – Officers arrive at a business on Hayden Rd and find an adult dead from a gunshot; two suspects claim self‑defense and are detained while detectives probe a possible attempted robbery motive [16].

Jan 8, 2026 – A shooting in the 1200 block of East Hudson Street leaves a victim with a facial wound; police detain a possible suspect and request public assistance [15].

Jan 11, 2026 – A dispute in a business parking lot on South High St leads to a fatal shooting; the victim dies after being taken to Grant Medical Center, and investigators await prosecutor review [14].

Jan 13, 2026 – Elijah Roberts pleads guilty to aggravated murder for the July 9, 2025 Target shooting and receives a life sentence with parole eligibility after 27 years, concluding a year‑long prosecution [13].

Jan 15, 2026 – A Franklin County grand jury indicts Antonio Colvin on reckless homicide for the Dec 22, 2025 accidental shooting of 2‑year‑old Va’Niyah Mason; Colvin’s next court appearance is scheduled for Friday [12].

Jan 16, 2026 – Police respond to a shooting on Nissi Drive in northeast Columbus, finding a juvenile wounded; no suspect information is released as detectives seek tips [11].

Jan 16, 2026 – A 17‑year‑old is shot on Talon Ct in north Columbus; after being listed critical, his condition improves, and two juveniles are arrested on aggravated robbery charges [10].

Jan 20, 2026 – Officers on Duvall Rd in Ashville engage a male subject during a sexual‑assault call; an officer fires, the subject dies at a Columbus hospital, and the Ohio BCI launches a state‑level investigation [9].

Jan 23, 2026 – Kenneth Milton is arrested and charged with murder after a fatal shooting in a Tamarack Blvd parking lot in northeast Columbus; he is booked and set to appear in court on Saturday [8].

Jan 27, 2026 – James Pettigrew, 31, is shot on South Richardson Ave in the Hilltop neighborhood; he dies at 3:53 p.m., and detectives request security video from the surrounding block while the public is urged to provide anonymous tips [7][4][2].

Feb 1, 2026 – A gunfire report near Ohio State University leads officers to West 10th Ave and North High St, where a man in his 50s is critically wounded; police note involvement of several male juveniles and ask for community assistance [6].

Feb 2, 2026 – US Marshals arrest 34‑year‑old Duron Thomas Sr. in Toledo for the July 28, 2024 Charley’s Place murder; he is held for extradition to Franklin County [5].

Feb 5, 2026 – Three men receive prison terms for the April 14, 2024 killing of teen Angel Diaz after pleading guilty to involuntary manslaughter; the case began with a ShotSpotter alert and involved a “switch” handgun [3].

Feb 24, 2026 – Columbus police ask the public to help identify four armed, dangerous persons of interest in the Jan 27, 2026 Hilltop shooting, providing a QR code for anonymous video submissions [2].

Feb 27, 2026 – The Freeman estate files a wrongful‑death suit against three Columbus officers, alleging they ignored repeated domestic‑violence threats and failed to seize a firearm that had a court‑ordered forfeiture; Fraternal Order of Police president Brian Steel calls the death “heartbreaking” but blames the shooter, while city data show 40 % of homicides involve domestic violence [1].

Dive deeper (13 sub-stories)

All related articles (28 articles)

External resources (2 links)