Kristi Noem’s Unfavorability Hits 37% as ICE Approval Drops to 44% After Minneapolis Shootings
Updated (14 articles)
Minneapolis Shootings Ignite National Backlash Against ICE The fatal shootings of Renee Good on Jan 7 and Alex Pretti on Jan 24 by federal immigration agents in Minneapolis sparked widespread protests and bipartisan calls for independent investigations [1][4][5]. Both incidents occurred during ICE operations that deployed Border Patrol agents inside the city, a tactic described by former ICE director Darius Reeves as “disastrous” [5]. The killings intensified scrutiny of ICE’s use of force and accelerated public demands for policy changes [2][3].
Poll Shows Kristi Noem’s Unfavorability Soars to 37% Harvard CAPS/Harris poll of 2,000 registered voters conducted Jan 28‑29 found Noem’s favorability at 24% and unfavorability at 37%, a seven‑point rise from December and a net rating of –13 [1]. The same survey recorded ICE approval at only 44%, the lowest among major institutions [1]. A DHS spokesperson dismissed the poll’s relevance, asserting Noem “doesn’t check with polls” when enforcing the law [1].
ICE Approval Plummets to Historic Lows Nationwide National surveys reported roughly 60% of Americans disapprove of ICE, with 59% labeling its deportation tactics “too aggressive” in a Fox News poll conducted Jan 23‑26 [2][4]. The Economist/YouGov poll showed 55% of respondents have very little confidence in ICE, up from 45% a month earlier [6]. These figures reflect a sharp decline from earlier 2025 levels and place ICE among the least trusted federal agencies [1][2].
Political Leaders Push for ICE Reform or Abolition Following the Minneapolis shootings, the White House and Congress launched reform negotiations, while Democrats such as Rep. Ayanna Pressley called ICE a “rogue, violent agency” and advocated stripping qualified‑immunity protections [2][3]. Retired ICE director Darius Reeves warned the agency may “not survive in its current form” and will need to rebuild “brick by brick” [5]. Polls indicate a majority now support cutting ICE’s budget, with 51% favoring reduced funding—more than for any other major spending category [6].
Trump Defends Noem While Administration Claims Record Safety President Donald Trump praised Noem’s border policies, saying she has done a “very good job” despite the polling dip [1]. The administration simultaneously touted historically low murder rates and a 21% drop in major‑city homicides in 2025, framing the period as the safest in a century [3]. Critics counter that declining arrest and clearance rates may mask unresolved violence, highlighting gaps in the safety narrative [3].
Sources
-
1.
Newsweek: Kristi Noem’s Unfavorability Surges as Poll Shows 37% Disapproval – Details the Jan 28‑29 Harvard CAPS/Harris poll, Noem’s rating drop, ICE’s 44% approval, and Trump’s defense of Noem .
-
2.
CNN: Americans’ Views on ICE Amid Reform Talks – Reports on post‑Pretti reform negotiations, national ICE disapproval rates, and partisan splits on ICE cooperation .
-
3.
Newsweek: Trump’s ICE Debate Amid Claims of Record‑Low Crime – Highlights Democratic calls to abolish ICE, CAP reform plan, and the administration’s low‑crime claims .
-
4.
Newsweek: Fox News Poll Finds 59% View ICE Deportations as Too Aggressive Amid Minneapolis Shootings – Presents the Jan 23‑26 Fox poll showing 59% deem deportations too aggressive and links to the Minneapolis shootings .
-
5.
Newsweek: ICE’s Future in Jeopardy After Minneapolis Shootings – Features retired ICE director Darius Reeves’ warning that the agency may collapse and critiques of interior‑city deployments .
-
6.
Newsweek: Civil Liberties Overtake Immigration as Top Voter Concern in Early 2026 – Shows civil liberties surpassing immigration in voter priority, plummeting confidence in ICE, and growing support for budget cuts .
Primary Data (2)
Quinnipac: Majority Of Voters Think Fatal Shooting Of Minneapolis Woman By Ice Agent Was Not Justified, Quinnipiac University National Poll Finds; 57% Of Voters Disapprove Of The Way Ice Is Enforcing Immigration Laws
Published (4 tables/charts)Pew: How Americans See Immigration Officers’ Behaviors and Civilian Actions
Published (3 tables/charts)Videos (1)
Timeline
Jan 7 2026 – ICE agent shoots 37‑year‑old Renee Nicole Good in Minneapolis; video shows her trying to drive away, sparking nationwide outrage and prompting calls for an independent investigation of ICE’s use of force[4][5].
Jan 9‑12 2026 – YouGov/The Economist poll finds 46 % of Americans now support abolishing ICE, up from 27 % in June 2025, while 43 % oppose abolition, marking the sharpest rise in abolition sentiment of the year[14].
Jan 13 2026 – Release of the YouGov/The Economist poll highlights the Minneapolis shooting of Good as the catalyst for the surge in abolition support and prompts Democratic lawmakers such as Rep. Rashida Tlaib to call for dismantling ICE[14].
Jan 14 2026 – Three major polls (CNN, Quinnipiac, Yahoo‑YouGov) show 56‑53 % of adults deem the Good shooting inappropriate and 2‑1 opposition to ICE among independents, with Democrats overwhelmingly condemning the action[4][5].
Jan 18 2026 – CBS News/YouGov poll reports 61 % of Americans say ICE tactics are “too tough,” up from 56 % in November, and 52 % believe ICE makes communities less safe, while a YouGov/Economist poll shows 46 % support abolishing ICE[13].
Jan 19 2026 – CNN poll reveals 56 % of respondents think the ICE agent who shot Good used force inappropriately and 51 % say ICE enforcement makes cities less safe, adding to broader criticism of ICE’s tactics[2].
Jan 22 2026 – At a White House briefing, President Trump says “ICE will make mistakes” and calls Good’s death “a horrible event,” signaling a softer tone toward ICE after earlier defenses[3].
Jan 23‑26 2026 – Fox News poll finds 59 % view ICE deportations as “too aggressive,” a 10‑point rise since July, and notes the recent killings of Good (Jan 7) and Alex Pretti (Jan 24) heighten scrutiny of ICE operations[8].
Jan 24 2026 – Alex Pretti, a 37‑year‑old nurse, is fatally shot by Border Patrol agents during an ICE operation in Minneapolis, prompting Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker and other Democrats to call for ICE’s abolition[7][8].
Jan 27 2026 – Reuters‑Ipsos poll shows only 39 % approve of Trump’s immigration handling and 58 % say ICE “has gone too far,” while more than 120 Democrats introduce a resolution to impeach DHS Secretary Kristi Noem over the Minneapolis killings[11].
Jan 27 2026 – CNN analysis reports record‑low net approvals for ICE (‑27), DHS (42 % favorable), and Noem (‑16), noting the Minneapolis shootings of Good and Pretti as the trigger for the plunge and that Trump dispatches border czar Tom Homan to Minneapolis[12].
Jan 28‑29 2026 – YouGov/The Economist weekly tracking shows civil‑liberties concerns overtake immigration as top voter issue for the first time, with 55 % expressing very little confidence in ICE and 51 % favoring budget cuts to the agency[9].
Jan 28‑29 2026 – Retired ICE director Darius Reeves tells Newsweek “ICE has no coming back from this” after the Pretti and Good shootings, warning the agency may collapse and will need to “rebuild brick by brick”[10].
Jan 29 2026 – Center for American Progress releases a policing‑reform plan that rejects “abolish” language, condemns ICE agents wearing masks, and the White House touts America’s lowest murder rate in a century, citing a 21 % drop in homicides in 2025[7].
Jan 30 2026 – The White House and Congress launch earnest negotiations on ICE reform after Pretti’s killing, focusing on a ban on mask‑wearing by agents and other accountability measures[1].
Jan 30 2026 – Lawmakers face a Friday funding deadline for the Department of Homeland Security, with Democrats seeking to attach constraints on ICE operations to the DHS appropriations bill[8].
Feb 3 2026 – Harvard CAPS/Harris poll shows Kristi Noem’s unfavorability climbs to 37 % (net ‑13) and ICE approval slips to 44 % amid the Minneapolis shootings, while a DHS spokesperson retorts, “the American people, the law, and common sense are on our side”[6].
Dive deeper (6 sub-stories)
-
Kristi Noem’s Unfavorability Jumps to 37% in January Poll Amid Border Controversy
(2 articles)
-
Reform Talks Accelerate After Pretti Killing, Public Confidence Plummets
(4 articles)
-
Poll Shows 59% View ICE Deportations as Too Aggressive After Minneapolis Shootings
(2 articles)
-
CNN: Trump and Vance soften ICE criticism as polls show broad opposition
-
Trump’s Greenland Push Rejected, ICE Scrutiny Grows, and Global Standing Declines
(4 articles)
-
Newsweek: Poll shows surge in support for abolishing ICE after Minneapolis shooting
All related articles (14 articles)
-
Newsweek: Kristi Noem’s Unfavorability Surges as Poll Shows 37% Disapproval
-
CNN: Americans’ Views on ICE Amid Reform Talks
-
Newsweek: Trump’s ICE Debate Amid Claims of Record‑Low Crime
-
Newsweek: Fox News Poll Finds 59% View ICE Deportations as Too Aggressive Amid Minneapolis Shootings
-
Newsweek: ICE’s Future in Jeopardy After Minneapolis Shootings
-
Newsweek: Civil Liberties Overtake Immigration as Top Voter Concern in Early 2026
-
Newsweek: ICE, DHS and Noem Approval Ratings Hit Historic Lows
-
Newsweek: Trump’s Immigration Approval Hits Record Low Amid Minneapolis Killings
-
CNN: Trump and Vance soften ICE criticism as polls show broad opposition
-
CNN: CNN poll shows Trump faces opposition on Greenland, ICE actions, and world standing
-
Newsweek: Poll finds more Americans say ICE tactics are too tough after Minneapolis shooting
-
CNN: Polls show broad public opposition to ICE after Minneapolis shooting
-
CNN: Poll finds half of Americans say ICE makes cities less safe after Minnesota shooting
-
Newsweek: Poll shows surge in support for abolishing ICE after Minneapolis shooting
External resources (21 links)
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gs0TF_D9hK0 (cited 2 times)
- https://law.marquette.edu/facultyblog/2025/12/attention-to-news-in-2025/ (cited 1 times)
- https://poll.qu.edu/images/polling/us/us01132026_trends_ubhu94.pdf (cited 1 times)
- https://poll.qu.edu/poll-release?releaseid=3944 (cited 1 times)
- https://www.ipsos.com/en-us/americans-have-mixed-reaction-us-removal-venezuelan-president (cited 1 times)
- https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2026/01/29/how-americans-see-immigration-officers-behaviors-and-civilian-actions/ (cited 1 times)
- https://www.pewresearch.org/race-and-ethnicity/2025/03/26/americans-views-of-deportations/ (cited 1 times)
- https://www.axios.com/local/twin-cities/2026/01/29/minneapolis-police-helping-ice-trump-frey-staffing (cited 1 times)
- https://www.foxnews.com/politics/fox-news-poll-59-voters-say-ice-too-aggressive-up-10-points-since-july (cited 1 times)
- https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2025/12/04/us/ice-arrests-criminal-records-data.html (cited 1 times)
- https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/01/22/polls/times-siena-national-poll-toplines.html (cited 1 times)
- https://www.reuters.com/world/us/trumps-immigration-approval-drops-record-low-reutersipsos-poll-finds-2026-01-26/ (cited 1 times)
- https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/26474159/cnn-poll-immigration-minneapolis-ice.pdf (cited 1 times)
- https://d3nkl3psvxxpe9.cloudfront.net/documents/cbsnews_20251102_1.pdf (cited 1 times)
- https://d3nkl3psvxxpe9.cloudfront.net/documents/cbsnews_20251123_1.pdf (cited 1 times)
- https://deportationdata.org/analysis/immigration-enforcement-first-nine-months-trump.html (cited 1 times)
- https://link.newsweek.com/join/79a/the-1600 (cited 1 times)
- https://www.americanprogress.org/article/fact-sheet-delivering-accountability-a-plan-to-stop-crime-in-our-communities/ (cited 1 times)
- https://www.scribd.com/document/980617250/Yahoo-YouGov-ICE-Poll-January-2026 (cited 1 times)
- https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/policy/immigration/4429865/jd-vance-ice-officers-discipline-mistakes-justified/ (cited 1 times)